Skip to main content

PhD Supervision

Effective supervision is imperative for the success of a doctoral programme. A productive and positive supervision relationship is the bedrock of a successful doctoral journey. Supervisors and students are encouraged to enter into conversation at the outset. The respective responsibilities of supervisors and students are outlined in the co-signed Memorandum of Understanding.

Every doctoral candidate must have one internal, FMHS-affiliated supervisor who has completed a supervision course, and ensures that they are familiar with up-to-date SU and FMHS policies and deadlines. An external main supervisor may be nominated as long as an internal co-supervisor who participates actively in the doctoral journey and is in a position to assure that the candidate works to SU and FMHS policies and deadlines, is also included in the supervision team.

The ideal number of supervisors depends on the supervision model. As a rule of thumb, two supervisors per student are ideal for lone-standing studies, whereas the allocation of up to a maximum of four supervisors per student can work well where several senior researchers are collaborating on a larger project, or where a cohort approach is taken. A proliferation of supervisors is generally not beneficial to a PhD. Over and above the suggested numbers, additional domain experts may be asked for once-off inputs on specific aspects of the study; bearing in mind that the pool of possible reviewers and internal examiners shrinks whenever a colleague becomes involved in a PhD study.

 

Prerequisites for supervision
 

 

Leather bound thesis

 

Puzz;le pieces

 

seal

Hold a PhD

Know criteria

GCP certified

A doctoral supervisor should usually hold a PhD degree. With suitable motivation, an experienced specialist within a relevant domain who does not hold a PhD, may be nominated as a supervisor. Current students may not supervise a PhD. Internal supervisors must familiarise themselves with the FMHS Doctoral Guidelines; the SU Yearbook rules on doctoral degrees; and the national guidelines on doctoral graduate attributes.

Along with clinical PhD students, every supervisor of clinical research towards a PhD is expected to have active / up-to-date Good Clinical Practice (GCP) certification.

Team
Tree

 

collab

Eligible team 

Trained supervisors

Prior collaboration

Detailed information on eligibility for supervision is included in this document

An internal FMHS supervisor must be included in the team. Associates may fulfil this role. Current PhD students, Postdocs, and Emeritus Professors may not supervise research degree students enrolled in the FMHS.

The FMHS requires all doctoral supervisors to attend formal supervision training. Options: 
CREST Online Training for Supervisors of Doctoral Candidates at African Universities
Centre for Higher and Adult Education (CHAE) Postgraduate Supervision course
• More coming soon

The success of a PhD is strongly influenced by the working relationship amongst supervisors. In the case of joint degrees, previous collaboration is a prerequisite for appointing co-supervisors. A supervisor who has a connection with a supervisor at an SU joint degree partner, can consider recruiting for a joint degree (more information below).

Supervision reporting 

Hourglass
Image by: Stock

Progress reporting

Annual progress reporting on doctoral studies is compulsory in the FMHS. Doctoral students complete an annual progress report on which the supervisor comments and signs off in early October each year; along with supervisor motivations to Senate for exceeding the maximum PhD duration.

Supervisor typing

Final supervisor report

Upon completion of the PhD examination process, after a successful oral, the supervisor submits to the Doctoral Office, Tygerberg at [email protected] the final dissertation (signatures removed), a bullet list of changes made, and a final supervisor report, on this template.

Stellenbosch University campus

Institutional reporting

Academic environments report the involvement of PhD supervisors on SunStudent and to the FMHS Committee for Postgraduate Research (CPR). The percentage contribution of all supervisors is indicated. Create a SUN-ID for each external supervisor, connecting the supervisor to the environment.

Progress Reporting

Supervision reporting graphic
Image by: stock

Annual progress reporting on doctoral studies is compulsory in the FMHS. Doctoral students in the phase prior to ethics approval are required to submit an annual progress report, on which the supervisor must comment and sign off. In the case of returning students, an annual progress report is requested from the supervisor in October or early November every year. 

Supervisor motivations for a student to exceed the maximum duration of a PhD are required six months before the maximum registration period is reached. These motivation letters are scrutinised by the CPR, Faculty Board and Senate. They are requested together with the annual progress report by October each year, for every PhD student in year 5 or later who has not submitted a dissertation for examination in time for March/April graduation. These motivations are submitted to [email protected] during September each year.
 

Final supervisor report

Upon completion of the PhD examination process, after a successful oral, the supervisor submits to the Doctoral Office, Tygerberg at [email protected] the final dissertation (signatures removed), a bullet list of changes made, and a final supervisor report, on this template.
 

Reporting on Supervision 

Academic environments report the proportional involvement of supervisors of a PhD project on SU databases and to the FMHS Committee for Postgraduate Research (CPR). The percentage contribution of both internal and external supervisors should be indicated at these junctures. The following mechanism should be used to capture the % division of supervision accurately, both for internal and external supervisors: An identity for the external supervisor should be created on SUN-id and in the process, the individual should be connected to the correct department where they are delivering supervision. The person is linked to the relevant student as usual, but the person is identified as “external” and found using their US number (as created in SUN-id). This allows for both an accurate depiction of supervision workload and the correct flow of funds to the environment. (There is no detrimental impact on the subsidy portion allocated to departments.)
 

Joint Degrees 

 

Joint PhD degrees conducted by SU together with an international partner institution, offer students a rewarding and enriched research journey. Supervisors who regularly collaborate with colleagues at a specific institution abroad, may want to explore the possibility of initiating a joint degree. Joint degrees are negotiated at the institutional level and are not possible on a student-by-student basis. 
The success of a joint PhD is strongly influenced by a successful pre-existing working relationship between the co-supervisors at the two partner institutions.

A supervisor who has a constructive relationship with a supervisor at one of SU's joint degree partners, can consider recruiting students to do a joint degree between SU and any of the universities listed below. The details of each joint degree are structured by the institutional-level agreement covering the fee agreement, examination process, and more. 

More information on SU joint degrees may be found at this link.

globe with grad cap
Coventry UniversityErasmus University Rotterdam (EUR)Friedrich Schiller University of Jena (FSU)
Ghent UniversityHasselt UniversityKU Leuven
Radboud Universiteit Nijmegen​Reutlingen University (master’s only)Università degli Studi di Padova
Université Clermont AuvergneUniversité de BordeauxUniversité de Montpellier
Universiteit Antwerpen​University of Göttingen (master’s only)University of Groningen
University of HamburgUniversity of Leipzig (includes master's)Université Toulouse III - Paul Sabatier
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam (VUA)Vrije Universiteit Brussel 

 

 

 

forward together • sonke siya phambili • saam vorentoe